American Home Shield provides home warranty plans that cover the repair and replacement of major home systems and appliances for homeowners across the United States.
Each model independently rates American Home Shield on a 1–5 star scale.
Large US home warranty provider owned by Frontdoor Inc. Well-known brand but faces frequent consumer complaints about claim denials and contractor quality. Website currently unreachable raises minor concern.
American Home Shield is a home warranty provider with mixed reviews. The website timeout is a caution signal.
American Home Shield is a long-standing home warranty provider. While established, website inaccessibility is a caution. Scores reflect industry reputation, potential coverage limitations, and the current technical issue.
American Home Shield is a long‑standing U.S. home warranty provider (part of Frontdoor) with broad coverage but mixed customer experiences. Many complaints cite claim denials and contractor issues. State-level regulation applies. Their site was unreachable now, a caution signal.
Established US home warranty firm with decades of operation but widespread complaints on claim denials, slow service, and high fees. Website timeout signals caution. State-level licensing exists yet oversight is lighter than traditional insurance.
Other top-rated companies in Insurance.
Quick answers based on live TrustRating data. How we score companies →
American Home Shield is rated 2.7 out of 5 (“Poor”) on TrustRating, based on 5 independent AI model assessments. The TrustScore combines real customer reviews with AI models that independently assess trust, regulation, support and reputation signals. Always do your own research before making a purchase or investment.
TrustRating doesn't issue scam verdicts — we publish the data instead: American Home Shield scores 2.7 out of 5 (“Poor”) based on 5 independent AI model assessments. Every review passes TrustGuard, our fraud-screening system that blocks fake and paid reviews, so the score reflects genuine customer experience. Read the most recent reviews below before you decide.
American Home Shield currently has a TrustScore of 2.7 out of 5 (“Poor”). The score blends verified customer reviews with assessments from multiple independent AI models, and it updates automatically as new reviews and scans come in. You can read exactly how scores are computed on our methodology page.
You can compare American Home Shield against other top-rated companies in the Insurance category on TrustRating, ranked by TrustScore. See all Insurance companies →
